The Transformation of nypl.org

nypl.org home pages
Since 1994, NYPL.org has had nine home page designs. Can you put them in order from first to last? 
The answers will be in our next Digital Experience blog post. Stay tuned!

About a year ago, I stepped into a newly created role, Director of Digital Experience at The New York Public Library. The position came with an exciting and challenging charge: to transform how the Library creates digital experiences in both virtual and physical spaces, across programs, collections, and events throughout the institution. As a new department in the Library, we embarked on a new and exciting series of initiatives that includes the integration of digital experiences into our exhibition programs, working with the various educational programs to understand how we can better develop educational resources for the community, and our most immediate challenge, the redevelopment of the Library’s website.

You are reading this piece on nypl.org right now—so obviously, you use the Library’s website, which puts you in the category of “a lot of people.” As with so many organizations, corporations and institutions, the website is a key point of contact for many of our patrons. According to Mary Meeker’s presentation at this year's Code Conference, Internet usage since 1995 has grown worldwide from 35 million users to 2.8 billion, and from 1% to 39% population penetration. Locally, nationally, and globally, nypl.org serves millions of people per year who visit the website to see if a branch is open, put a hold on a book, find out who is speaking at Books at Noon, or when the next Photoshop class is being offered. Scholars, researchers, teachers and students explore our collection of databases, articles and other online resources. You can even see recorded events that have taken place at the Library—like our amazing LIVE from the NYPL series or Books at Noon program.

The Library’s website has grown since its original launch over 20 years ago. More and more information, programming and media has be integrated into the site. The site has become more complex, and being able to discover all the amazing things in The New York Public Library is getting more and more difficult to do on the site. We’ve also come to realize that many of the new technologies that can allow us to connect with communities, create a dialog with our experts and patrons, and make use of new interactive tools is becoming harder and harder to integrate into our aging technical infrastructure.

It’s time for an upgrade!

While there’s a great number of resources on the site, we know we can make it better. We can make it easier to find things. We can offer you the opportunity to connect to communities and resources here at the library. We can offer you more access to our fantastic staff, our collections and our expertise. We can make it easier to attend a class, a lecture or ask a librarian a question. We can create a more personal experience and help you get the most out of this great community institution. We want to make the site easier to use, and easier to access, if you are looking at it on a desktop computer, tablet or smartphone.

In order to do that, we need to rebuild, redesign, and reorganize. We’ve launched a web redevelopment project that will take us into next year and allow us to begin offering new interfaces, new online tools, and new ways for you to interact with NYPL.  You’ll start seeing some of these changes later this fall as we really begin to roll up our sleeves and start building the new digital platform. There’s a great deal to do, with much needed re-tooling of the backend site structure as part of this initial effort, so many of the changes may not be immediately apparent.

We've just completed a 12-week concept phase of the redevelopment of the site. Working with the Portland, Oregon design firm Second Story, we kicked off the phase with a high-intensity boot-camp week of interviews with library departments and staff aimed at assessing everyone’s needs, and we’ve kept everyone at NYPL as involved as possible as the project has progressed. We completed an inventory of all our web content—and there is quite a lot—and created a series of visual designs to establish a design direction after receiving feedback from across our 92 branches. In addition, we began an assessment of the site's infrastructure and began exploring how new web technologies could be integrated into the new environment. Our vision for the site’s rollout is a continuation of the process. Parts of the site will be available in its first appearance while others will be developed in tandem. And even after the whole thing is “complete,” it still won’t be “done.” NYPL is always re-evaluating what it can provide for the public, and our approach to the new website will follow this philosophy.

At this time, the culmination of the concept phase, we’ve developed an initial visual treatment, not a final design, but a general visual direction that incorporates some of the new features and ideas we’ve been discussing. This is a small representation of a much larger design scope, but I’d like to share it with you to give you an idea of some of the potential changes and features we might develop further. Click the video below to see some samples:

Over the next few months we'll be posting our progress on the overall project, soliciting your input, and introducing you to the team that is making this happen. For starters, I’d like to offer the following email address:

webfeedback@nypl.org

If you have any thoughts, ideas, or features you think we should consider, feel free to send me a note and let me know what you are thinking. I’ll definitely read them and consider your feedback as we move through the process of this web redevelopment.

I’ve invited members of the Digital Experience group to contribute to this blog as well. In the coming months, you’ll hear from people who are helping to reshape the cornerstone of the Library’s digital platform. We hope this window into the design of the new website is interesting and exciting to you as it is to us, and please feel free to drop us a line to let us know how we are doing.

Comments

Patron-generated content represents the views and interpretations of the patron, not necessarily those of The New York Public Library. For more information see NYPL's Website Terms and Conditions.

New Web Page

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE keep it as simple as possible. It took me 15 minutes to make the damn thing let me sign in last night, couldn't find the e-book section which was formerly a separate site - I searched and searched to find where to check out books for my Kindle - God forbid I would actually find some of the best mystery writers still available in either print or electronic form, but...sorry, just please don't sacrifice the usability of the site for the pretty face and endless buttons to click. Thanks.

We hear you!

We're definitely working on the overall navigation! The old site has grown organically, and has become somewhat of an information design nightmare! We've done a great deal of thinking about how our visitors will move through the site. I think you'll find the new design much easier to follow.

NY Public Library

The NY Public Library branches should take a look at the Broward County Library in Florida. If Florida can develop a beautiful, functional library surely NYC can do at least as well if not better. I literally grew up in the Hunts Point Branch of the library in the Bronx and it was a wonderful refuge for me and my friends. Surely we can do as well or better in 2015.

We will!

That's our goal! To improve this site and bring it up to date! Thanks for your comments and the pointer to Broward!

Is there any update on

Is there any update on changing the way the website works. Just change it to how it was before and everything will be fixed. Currently most of the basic functionality is broken. 1) Login , very hard to find login 2) After you find the login it ask for new catalog and old, How do a user know understand what is new and old. 3) Sort by due date does not work 4) UI is so bad , very bad not at all friendly One simple solution revert back to the old website, it was a piece of art by smart people.

Access from ipad or iphone

I,was looking forward to looking at your new look...but right away the first opportunity to put home page option on order was not something I could do with my ipad. Others may be accessing via tablets etc and not jist computers, if so, please include us.

Don't worry- It will be mobile compatible!

We are including a responsive, mobile design, so it will function on your tablet and phone!

Access from ipad or iphone

I,was looking forward to looking at your new look...but right away the first opportunity to put home page option on order was not something I could do with my ipad. Others may be accessing via tablets etc and not jist computers, if so, please include us.

Classic Catalog

1. Often, if I search a book by Title, the NYPL doesn't have it. But if I then search the same book by Author, the NYPL does have the book! 2. Many times, I've suggested a title that the NYPL does not have. But I have never received either an acknowledgement of my suggestion, or a follow-up as to whether or not the NYPL has decided to purchase the title!

Classic catalog-

Thanks for your note- I think you might want to visit ask.nypl.org and see how you can follow up on requests. It's a great, friendly staff, with answers to questions about NYPL.

Tabs for online catalog

I am a school librarian in NYC who encourages her students to use NYPL as a resource for print, audio, and electronic books and research. This pass year alone, I helped 60+ students sign up for a library card and took about 35 of them on a field trips to the library closest to our school on the Upper West Side, Bloomingdale. When teaching them to navigate NYPL's website, a consistent complaint was that link to the online catalog was "hidden" under a tab marked Explore. When designing the new website, please make the online catalog it's own tab or at least easier to find. We don't want anyone - let alone children - to give up the search before they even begin.

Making it easier-

......to find things! That's one of our priorities. Most people come to the website to look at the catalog. We're working on a few things here that will improve that experience-from a new overall interface, to making search results more efficient. Let me know if you have a group of students who would be interested in giving us some feedback on the design. We'd love to hear what they have to say. We've also been thinking about creating a special search interface for younger students, and hopefully we can start working on that in the next few months. Thanks for your note.

e-audio

I'm a former employee of NYPL. I'm disabled and have worked for the Andrew Heiskell branch, as well as used the audiobooks available there. Can NYPL ever offer copies of some of those audiobooks available from the LOC, when no other audio copy exists? One of my favorite books of all time is only available, on tape, from the Library for the Blind and Physically Handicapped. I'm not saying that it's great literature, but I LOVE that book (not an uncommon emotion among book lovers) . I'd love to have access to a digital copy of it, with the same narrator and same rendition as the AHLBPH copy, made available by NYPL for all patrons. Many thanks, Sue Strong

Digital Experience Director

Digital Experience Director Frank Migliorelli: Dear NYPL, I would like to leave a feedback for you the new updates done to the website. Before that I would like to say that I love NYPL and have appreciated its website earlier. Today was disappointed with the changes done in the website. It is not a user friendly experience and we haven't tried it on mobile yet only tested on PC ( IE/Chrome) 1) Very hard to find login ( I had to hunt for login in various menus ). 2) Where is the search bar/box, I have to click on logo to get the search box. First thing people do is search on this site 3) Mega menus are good what happen to Main Menu it does not look/feel like Main-menu. It seems like just text and easy to confuse and the animation/dropdown design is not user friendly. 4) Why did not you use the v1/beta version approach and let users give you feedback before this failure. How do you expect the senior/ new user to learn if existing users are having problem 5) What happen to the My Checkout / My Hold - they were so easy not its even hard to renew material. With all the due respect for the hard work you have placed in updating the new design is not as simple as earlier. Please Please revert back this failure. Get a better user experience/ designer in the developer team. Sorry I could not explain clearly in words without the help of Pictures or screen share.

I couldn't agree with you

I couldn't agree with you more. This new site is an epic failure for which someone should be fired. (Let's spend that salary on books!) Simply put, the library's primary function should be to offer books and other media for check out. But that is now the least of their concerns. Apparently it's all about podcasts and blogs and events. That stuff is great but should not be the library's primary purpose. I miss the old lists feature. I miss being able to see what I have checked out or what I have on hold. I hate having to click around to two or three pages to do something that used to require a simple click of the mouse. I have written to every email address I can find at the library to see who is in charge of this stupidity. No one will take responsibility. Clearly they realized that they have failed and are in a position in which they shouldn't be. Pathetic. The waste of taxpayers dollars is repulsive. But as they remind you on every link, be sure and donate cause they need books!

login problem

how do I login , what did you guys do to the website. Oh god

the new website is just not good

I'm all for upgrading things, but too often in technology people 'upgrade' things to make them flashy and lose most of the easy use they had before. The new NYPL website simply does not work - it's confusing, it's weirdly worded, it's hard to even figure out how to search for a book, and i've spent the last 20 minutes trying to figure out how to download a book to my kindle and as far as I can tell that option has just been removed from the website. I honestly do not understand how businesses continue to make these horrible mistakes. I only use the BPL website now because it is literally the only one I can figure out how to use. It has the old NYPL model which, while it's not perfect, it actually works and is relatively easy to understand. PLEASE fix this website - forget the flashyness, forget the nonsense, just make it simple and work. There's a reason google.com is the most used website on the internet: it's one word and a search bar. KEEP IT SIMPLE AND CLEAR.

I think you forget about your users...

I was one of those users who was pretty excited to see what NYPL was going to do to upgrade the experience. I am so thoroughly frustrated and disappointed with what has been released that I can barely get the words out. I am a web designer and focus heavily on UX/UI. I was hoping for good things for this project since you are working with Second Story (which seemed like an odd choice for this project given that they are interactive experience specialists, not "interactive web") It's amazing to me that even in your blog post you say that you kicked off the project doing interviews to find out what everyone needs-- and here you list everyone INTERNAL to the organization-- and don't mention USERS at all. So I guess I should not be surprised that this is an epic fail for users. When this launched I immediately upgraded the app on my phone and Ipad -- only to find that they are completely dysfunctional. I can't do anything I used to do. I am forced to go to the desktop to add a book to my reading list for the future. The bookbag checkout adds additional steps to a process that used to be easy. I used to look forward to getting book ideas from friends because it was so easy to add them to my list for later reading. Now it's impossible. I might as well go back to my old method of post-it notes on my desk. What used to be a pleasurable experience no matter what platform I was on is now a torturous experience.

THIS IS NOT AN IMPROVEMENT

Who is responsible for this new site? Why is there no longer a functioning app either? What a complete waste of taxpayers money. Whoever is in charge of this should be fired.

ABORTION OF A WEBSITE

My husband and I have been huge fans and patrons of the NYPL for decades. We use the website to reserve and renew books constantly. Not any more. You have made the site so counter intuitive that it is frightening. Fortunately we discovered the old catalog version but even that has its problems. What were you thinking? Please go back to the old format.

UPGRADE = UNUSABLE

I echo the prior 3 comments. This site is now painful and borderline unusable. As is the app. What is the intention here? Things use to work smoothly. I could easily place holds, add to my reading list, and manage requests. Everything is now a terrible chore. The app is even worse. It looks like it was designed in 10 minutes. Just add me to the list of very dissatisfied patrons. Your redesign is going in the entirely wrong direction.

Please direct your queries to

Please direct your queries to . 1) Jane Aboyoun, Vice President of Technology 212-621-0661 2) Director, Library Services 212-930-0716 3) Frank Migliorelli ( Digital Experience Director) webfeedback@nypl.org They are the authority figure for any changes and I believe will positively understand the pain we are going through. The new website is a EPIC EPIC FAILURE

Unfortunately they do not

Unfortunately they do not respond to any emails any longer and are doing absolutely nothing about fixing this site. It's horrid and they know it. And the app is even worse. Actually there is once again no longer an app. I just tried opening it and it doesn't work at all. So I spent 15 minutes updating holds and lists using the website, doing tasks that would have taken me about two minutes with the old user friendly functioning site.

What else can we say MAY GOD

What else can we say MAY GOD BLESS US, NYPL is one of the best libraries and someone managed to mess the website of one of the best public service institute. How can someone get away with this ? I just check today simple thing like "sorting by date" is not working

Frank Migliorelli ( Digital Experience Director)

Frank, Our old nypl.org website was nice and clean. It was very user friendly and helpful now it is a mess . Nothing to blame on no one , I believe good people had good intentions yet the output is a mess. Can you PLEASE do something look at the comments on the post, every one is facing the pain of new website. Comments at the nypl.org http://www.nypl.org/blog/2015/06/15/transformation-nypl-website#comment-21805

Is this website EVER going to

Is this website EVER going to be fixed? Will there ever be a working app?

No one even responds to this

No one even responds to this site anymore. it sucks.