Biblio File

15 Eerie and Unnerving Novels That Will Get Under Your Skin

wood engraving of people walking on the street
Along The Docks Of New York. NYPL Digital Collection, Image ID: 805647

A while back, we had a patron who was looking for “unexpectedly spooky” fiction in the realm of science or history that “steps outside the bounds of reality in a ghostly way.” We absolutely loved that description and came up with an amazing list of novels that fit the bill. Check out these perfect October reads for folks who like eerie but aren’t into horror. 

Spooky History

Lincoln In the Bardo   Grace by Natashia Deon    Affinity by Sarah Waters    Galore by Michael Crummey

Lincoln in the Bardo by George Saunders—President Lincoln, in the depths of his grief, visits the grave of his 11-year old son in a novel which blurs the states of reality.

Grace by Natashia Deón—Dual narratives, one with flashbacks about the life of a runaway slave who is killed moments after giving birth, and the other following the daughter as she faces the life her mother had hoped to protect her from.
 
Affinity by Sarah Waters—A con artist and medium convinces a well-meaning but vulnerable young woman to help her escape from prison.
 
Galore by Michael Crummey—The ripple effect of mysteries from ages past affects six generations of a family in small town Newfoundland in this vaguely magical and mystical novel.
 

Spooky Science

Annihilation    Sweet Tooth    The Dream of Perpetual Motion

Annihilation by Jeff Vandermeer—Four researchers set out to map and understand the quarantined zone Area X, a mission that eleven previous expeditions have failed at. Book 1 of the Southern Reach Trilogy.

Sweet Tooth by Jeff Lemire—A pandemic wipes out vast swaths of humanity, and many who are born after are human/animal hybrids. Gus is rescued by a man who he isn’t sure whether he can trust, but he has no other options.

The Dream of Perpetual Motion by Dexter Palmer—With his only companions being his insane lover and her cryogenically frozen father, greeting card writer Harold Winslow must come to terms with the madness of a genius inventor in this eerie steampunk fantasy.
 
Gold Fame Citrus      Rosewater      Age of Miracles
 
Gold Fame Citrus by Claire Vaye Watkins—In this climate dystopia by NYPL Young Lions Fiction winner Watkins, a couple and an orphaned toddler set out in a drought-ridden landscape.
 
Rosewater by Tade Thompson—A town springs up near a mysterious alien biodome. Some people are curious to know what’s inside, and others would prefer to never see it again.
 
The Age of Miracles by Karen Thompson Walker—The earth’s rotation has suddenly started to slow, and 11-year-old narrator Julia watches its impact on her family. Will society stick to an arbitrary 24-hour schedule, or will the “real-timers” prevail in adapting to longer and longer days and nights?
 

Vaguely Ghostly Fiction

Sing Unburied Sing    Hotel World    She Weeps Each Time You're Born

Sing, Unburied, Sing by Jesmyn Ward —Characters are both literally and figuratively haunted by their pasts in this moving story about racism, incarceration, loss, and complicated families.

Hotel World by Ali Smith—This novel centers around the death of a young chambermaid at a hotel and four women whose lives were touched by hers.

She Weeps Each Time You're Born by Quan Barry—A young girl in Vietnam realizes she can hear voices of the dead. As she flees her homeland, we learn of the history of her country and her family through the voices of ghosts that speak to her.

The Ghosts of Bergen County      The Lovely Bones

Ghosts of Bergen County by Dana Cann—What if the regret that haunts you becomes inexplicably embodied? The death of Gil’s young daughter brings him to a dark place, full of characters driven by their own regret and uncertainty.

The Lovely Bones by Alice Sebold—14-year-old Susie watches from the afterlife as her family copes with the aftermath of her rape and murder.

 


Have trouble reading standard print? Many of these titles are available in formats for patrons with print disabilities.

Staff picks are chosen by NYPL staff members and are not intended to be comprehensive lists. We'd love to hear your ideas too, so leave a comment and tell us what you’d recommend. And check out our Staff Picks browse tool for more recommendations!